Westinghouse withdraws from Ontario reactor bidding
Only two firms remain in running for province's $26-billion plan
Globe and Mail: KAREN HOWLETT AND SHAWN MCCARTHY - November 27, 2008http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20081127.wnukes27/EmailBNStory/energy/
TORONTO, OTTAWA U.S. nuclear giant Westinghouse Electric Co. LLC is taking itself out of the running to build new reactors in Ontario, raising concerns that a bidding process created by the provincial government to get the best deal for electricity consumers has become decidedly uncompetitive.
The government wants a company to design and build reactors on a so-called turnkey, fixed-price basis in the hopes of avoiding the mistakes of past nuclear projects, which saddled Ontarians with billions of dollars in debts. But sources in the nuclear industry said Westinghouse officials want to just supply technology rather than assume responsibility for a turnkey operation because of concerns about how much of the risk the company would be asked to assume for any cost overruns and delays.
A Westinghouse spokesman did not return telephone messages yesterday. A spokeswoman for Infrastructure Ontario, the provincial agency responsible for overseeing the government's $26-billion plan to build new reactors, insisted yesterday that Westinghouse remains "actively engaged in the process."
However, George Smitherman, Ontario's Minister of Energy and Infrastructure, confirmed that Westinghouse would prefer to play a more modest role.
"It seemed from the beginning that was a company that was more interested in supplying their technology than in actually building their technology," Mr. Smitherman told The Globe and Mail yesterday.
The Ontario government plans to build the province's first new reactors in more than two decades at the Darlington nuclear station in Clarington, a fast-growing community about 80 kilometres east of Toronto. The sources said the public interest is best served with a competitive process, but only two companies - Crown-owned Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. and France's Areva Group - are in the running to provide the complete, turnkey package.
"If they're down to two, where's the competition?" asked an executive who requested not to be named.
Greenpeace energy campaigner and nuclear opponent Shawn-Patrick Stensil noted that another potential bidder, U.S. nuclear giant GE-Hitachi Nuclear Energy Inc., also decided last spring not to bid on the project. The fact that the government has twice delayed the deadline for bids - to an unspecified date early in 2009 - shows that its push to build new reactors has hit a snag at a time when the costs for such projects are escalating, Mr. Stensil said.
"It doesn't look like they have a good chance of insulating the Ontario ratepayer from the financial cost of building a reactor," he said.
Mr. Smitherman said he is optimistic that the government will complete its plan to meet the province's electricity needs over the next two decades.
"At the end of the day, it takes one [company] to build it," he said.
Bryne Purchase, a former deputy energy minister in Ontario who is director of the energy and environment program at Queen's University, said AECL and Areva are going head to head.
"It's not as fulsome a competition but it is still a competition," he said.
While Areva is serious about winning, Dr. Purchase questioned whether the Harper government is equally committed, or whether it is looking for political cover to get out of the nuclear business.
"If they win, they're in the business," he said. "If they don't Ontario would have put a bullet in the head" of AECL.
Ontario and Ottawa are each waiting for a signal from the other about its commitment to AECL and the company's Candu technology. Ontario wants to ensure that the federal government will remain the principal shareholder and backstop AECL financially. Ottawa is hoping for a positive result in the Ontario bid to increase the long-term value of AECL's business.
The Harper government is also in the throes of deciding whether to sell AECL. Sources say no decision is imminent, but several key ministers, including Finance Minister Jim Flaherty, are said to be in favour of an outright sale.
Industry sources said nuclear vendors are concerned about the amount of risk they would have to take on should they win the project, and are particularly concerned about cost overruns that could arise if federal regulators take longer than anticipated to approve the reactor's design.
Dr. Purchase said Ontario is apparently signalling it would be willing to assume more of the risk on cost overruns than it had originally intended.
"They're getting push-back from everyone on that," he said. "There is so much uncertainty in the world right now that nobody wants to take on more risk than they have to."